Discuss some of the similarities and differences between the two films you have studied for this topic with particular reference to narrative and film genres.
Narrative:
The journey the characters go through, ‘Todorov’s theory or a story plan. Relates to ‘Full Metal Jacket’ And ‘Empire of the Sun’
Genre features?
Common things found in that Genre:
The characters, ‘Propp’ Hero, Villain, Helper. what the character represent in the films. Differences between story and narrative. Empire shows more of a physiological effect. FMJ is both, contains emotion highlighting the sociological side and physical. the journey the characters go through is similar. Both key on showing how war is, they are true. Both have iconic symbols and conventions that are common in a war film. Genre features, being patriotism… FMJ slates the naivety of Americans and their patriotism. Empire shows that America are in it for their own personal gain, represented by Casey (John Malcovitch). This is also highlighted in catch 22 with the character that sells medication nad equipment to make money, my personal opinion is that this character is showing how money is the source or most things.
For the other Question, Messages and Values.
Lions for lambs has strong values and messages, a film about the political side of war, and how people word their way around it to conceal their mistakes and try to show its right. Catch -22 can relate in a way. The messages are the main point of the film, the whole Catch 22 being that they only way to leave war is to leave on a section 8 but as soon as you ask to leave on a section 8, you are no longer classed as a section 8 and have to fly.
PLAN!
think about what the question asks?
‘How far do the 2 films you have studied for this topic present messages and values?’
Answered will be based around 2 films and the messages and values they have
what they present?
so not just what they are, what they say. Denotation/Connotation.
How they present them and how much… so the characters, the narrative, the mise en scene. Lions for lambs, the mise en scene shows suits Tye smart dress, college grounds, class rooms, offices. It uses props locations and costume to show that a war is fought just as much on home soil and formally than it is with violence.